Why would a company have better odds of transforming in the middle of a crisis? You’d think the ideal time to change would be when orders are strong, cash is available, and the leadership team can afford to experiment. Try telling a plant manager that the last Friday of a record quarter is the perfect time to take a production line down. See how much of that appetite for experimentation makes it to the shop floor.
A BCG study of roughly 1,700 corporate transformations set a demanding test for success. Companies had to accelerate growth relative to their industry peers and beat them on shareholder returns. Over three years, 28% of transformations launched in stronger economic years met that test, compared with 43% of those launched at the onset of COVID-19.
I wonder how much of that difference comes down to what a crisis lets a leader say out loud. “Yes, you can miss this month’s number to fix the thing that puts us behind every month.” In ordinary times, a manager may hear the same encouragement at a town hall and have good reason to doubt it. She remembers what happened to the last person who had to explain a bad month.
What one Friday shift is worth
Imagine you run a plant where Saturday overtime has become predictable enough that people plan their weekends around it. The production schedule looks fine on Monday morning. By Thursday, a late order has moved to the front of the queue, the line has changed over twice more than planned, and somebody is asking the Saturday crew to come in again. Your planners and operators have worked out a different way to sequence orders. They’ve tested it against last month’s production data. Now they need a shift on the actual line to find out whether it holds up when a customer changes an order halfway through the day. There’s a window this Friday. There’s also a shipment you promised to get out the door. If you run the trial, every unit you give up on Friday will be on a report by Monday morning. If the trial works, the benefit will arrive one quiet Saturday at a time. Nobody gets an alert when an overtime shift never happens. And if you postpone the trial? The shipment goes out, the dashboard stays green, and you might even get a thank-you for getting the order out on time.
Now imagine headquarters reviewing the project a month later. The sponsor sees another missed milestone and concludes that the plant manager hasn’t bought into the transformation. I’d ask a different question. If she understood exactly how this company evaluates good managers, what would you have expected her to do?
What the bonus plan can tell you
According to research from The Conference Board, financial measures typically carry 70% to 75% of the weight in short-term executive incentive plans at U.S. public companies that use both financial and nonfinancial measures. Profit and cash flow deserve a prominent place. The trouble starts when a manager can improve this year’s payout by postponing an investment that everyone, including the person who designed the bonus plan, agrees the business needs.
In a Manufacturing Leadership Council survey, 86% of respondents expected effective use of manufacturing data to be essential to competitiveness by 2030. Asked whether collecting, managing or analyzing data figured in executives’ annual incentives, KPIs or business priorities, only 22% gave an unqualified yes. Imagine being the engineer asked to sort out inconsistent downtime codes across every line. You can explain why the work matters. What you need is a supervisor willing to release an experienced operator to help you do it.
Three decisions to make before kickoff
If I had the executive team in the room, I’d spend a little less time debating how to announce the transformation and a little more time working through an actual Friday on the production calendar.
Agree on the trade-off while there’s still time to plan. Pick the shift, identify which orders can move, and have the person who owns the output target approve the change. Give the plant manager an answer she can use when the shipping supervisor asks whose decision this was.
Count the Saturdays the crew gets back. Track Saturday overtime alongside on-time delivery. The team deserves credit if it gets people home for the weekend and keeps its promises to customers. Reporting both would also show whether the new schedule simply pushed late orders into the following week.
Decide who shares the cost of success. Suppose the trial works and three other plants want to borrow the planner who made it happen. Her home plant will pay for coverage while the other sites collect the savings. Work out who funds that coverage before asking her manager to be a team player.
The part I’d pay closest attention to comes after the kickoff. It’s Monday morning, the trial ran, and the output number is red. Does the executive who approved the trial open the meeting by asking the manager to explain the shortfall? Or does that executive say, “I approved Friday. What did we learn, and when will we know whether it was worth it?” Everybody else in the room is listening. They’ve got decisions like Friday’s coming up, too.
That’s why I’d put the bonus plan on screen at the next transformation kickoff. Then I’d hand the microphone to the plant manager. She’s earned the right to ask the question everybody else is thinking.
Which target are you willing to let me miss to deliver the change you just asked for?
References:
Brousell, D. R., Moskowitz, S., & Puma, J. (2024, June). Data mastery: A key to industrial competitiveness. Manufacturing Leadership Council. https://manufacturingleadershipcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/M2030-Project-Survey-Results-DEL.pdf
Hodgson, P., & Jones, A. (2026, August 20). What companies reward: The changing mix of metrics in executive incentive pay. Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance. https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2026/08/20/what-companies-reward-the-changing-mix-of-metrics-in-executive-incentive-pay/
Seppä, T., Ellmer, K., Holmbom, A., Klemmer, D. C., Catchlove, P., Reeves, M., Pidun, U., Bouslov, G., & Job, A. (2025, April 16). The transformation paradox: How to grow when the growing gets tough. Boston Consulting Group. https://www.bcg.com/publications/2025/transformation-paradox-how-grow-when-growing-gets-tough